Oakland County Prosecuting Attorney

Why the Case Against Ethan Crumbley’s Parents Is So Unusual

Ethan Crumbley's Parents

When it comes to criminal cases, there is always a unique set of circumstances surrounding each one. However, the case against Ethan Crumbley’s parents is particularly unusual and has garnered significant attention from the media and the public.

What does a case against parents entail?

Typically, when a case involves minors, especially if they are involved in a criminal act, the focus is primarily on the minors themselves. However, in the case of Ethan Crumbley, who was charged with killing four students and injuring several others at his high school, the prosecution also decided to bring charges against his parents.

Prosecutors argue that the parents played a significant role in enabling their son to commit the heinous act. They claim that the parents bought the gun used in the shooting just days before the incident, and even received a concerning note from their son, yet failed to take any action to prevent the tragedy.

How and why are parents held responsible?

The decision to hold parents legally responsible for the actions of their children is not common. The legal principle of “parental liability” is often limited to civil cases, such as when parents are sued for their child’s negligence or intentional harm. However, in this case, the prosecution is attempting to establish that the parents’ actions, or lack thereof, contributed to the criminal act committed by their son.

Prosecutors argue that the parents’ failure to secure the gun and address their son’s concerning behavior, coupled with their alleged knowledge of his potential for violence, demonstrates a level of negligence and complicity that rises to the level of criminal liability.

How much does it cost?

When it comes to legal fees, the cost of mounting a defense against criminal charges can vary significantly depending on several factors.

The complexity of the case, the experience and reputation of the defense attorney, the jurisdiction in which the trial takes place, and the length of the trial are all factors that can contribute to the overall cost.

While it is difficult to provide an exact figure, criminal defense attorneys’ fees can range from several thousand dollars to hundreds of thousands of dollars, depending on the circumstances. It is crucial for individuals facing criminal charges or their parents to consult with an experienced attorney to discuss the potential costs associated with mounting a defense in a case like this.

What can parents recover?

In cases where parents are charged for their child’s actions, the potential consequences can be severe and life-altering. If found guilty, parents may face significant fines, probation, community service, or even incarceration.

Moreover, the emotional toll of such a case can be immeasurable. Dealing with the guilt of knowing that their actions or inactions contributed to a tragic event can have long-lasting effects on parents’ mental well-being.

How to hire an attorney for such cases?

When facing criminal charges, especially in cases where parents are implicated, it is essential to seek legal representation from an experienced criminal defense attorney.

Here are some steps to consider when hiring an attorney for a case like this:

  1. Research and compile a list of potential attorneys who specialize in criminal defense.
  2. Consider their experience, track record, and reputation in handling similar cases.
  3. Arrange initial consultations with the shortlisted attorneys to discuss the details of the case and gauge their understanding and approach.
  4. Ask about their fees, payment plans, and any additional costs associated with the defense.
  5. Evaluate their communication style and availability to ensure that you can effectively collaborate throughout the legal process.
  6. Ultimately, select an attorney whom you feel comfortable with and trust to provide the best possible defense.

Advantages and disadvantages of holding parents responsible

While the decision to hold parents responsible for the criminal actions of their children may seem justified in some cases, it also raises significant legal and ethical concerns.


  • Ensuring parents take an active role in their children’s lives and prevent them from engaging in criminal activities.
  • Sending a strong message to parents about their responsibility to raise law-abiding citizens.
  • Providing accountability for parental negligence or failure to address concerning behavior.


  • Potential for unfairly punishing parents who may have made genuine efforts to address their child’s issues.
  • Placing an undue burden on parents who may already be dealing with the emotional and financial consequences of their child’s actions.
  • Creating a precedent that could lead to broader interpretations of parental liability in future cases.

Where to find the best defense attorney?

When it comes to finding the best defense attorney for a case involving criminal charges against parents, thorough research and careful consideration are crucial.

Here are some recommended approaches to find the best defense attorney:

  • Seek referrals from trusted friends, family members, or legal professionals who may have knowledge of reputable criminal defense attorneys.
  • Consult local bar associations or legal aid organizations for recommendations.
  • Use online directories and search engines to find attorneys specializing in criminal defense who have positive reviews and testimonials.
  • Review attorney websites and online profiles to gauge their experience, credentials, and track record in handling similar cases.
  • Schedule initial consultations with a few attorneys to discuss your case and assess their expertise and fit for your specific needs.

Remember, finding the best defense attorney is a critical step in building a strong defense and protecting your rights in a case like this.

Sex ring using Madison Heights motels busted by human trafficking unit

Madison Heights Motels

Human trafficking is a heinous crime that affects countless individuals worldwide. Recently, a sex ring operating in Madison Heights motels was dismantled by the dedicated efforts of a human trafficking unit.

What does a sex trafficking ring involve?

A sex trafficking ring typically involves individuals or groups who engage in the coercion, abduction, recruitment, or transportation of individuals for the purpose of sexual exploitation.

In the case of the sex trafficking ring in Madison Heights, authorities discovered an organized network of individuals who were forcing victims into prostitution by leveraging various tactics, including physical violence, threats, and manipulation.

How an investigation into sex trafficking unfolds

Investigating sex trafficking cases requires a collaborative effort between law enforcement agencies, victim support organizations, and other relevant entities. Here is a general overview of the steps involved in an investigation:

  1. Identifying potential victims through tips, reports, or proactive operations.
  2. Gathering evidence through surveillance, undercover operations, and interviews with potential victims, witnesses, and suspects.
  3. Partnering with victim support organizations to ensure the safety and well-being of victims.
  4. Building a case against the perpetrators by connecting the evidence and establishing their involvement in the sex trafficking ring.
  5. Arresting the individuals involved and bringing charges against them.
  6. Continued support for the victims, including providing access to medical care, counseling, and legal assistance.

How much does it cost to investigate and prosecute sex trafficking cases?

Investigating and prosecuting sex trafficking cases can be a complex and resource-intensive process.

The cost will vary depending on various factors, including:

  • The duration and extent of the investigation.
  • The number of law enforcement personnel involved.
  • Forensic analysis, including digital evidence examination.
  • Witness protection and support services.
  • Legal fees and court expenses.

While it is challenging to provide an exact figure, it is crucial for law enforcement agencies and relevant organizations to allocate adequate resources to combat sex trafficking effectively and ensure justice for the victims.

What can victims recover?

Sex trafficking survivors often face significant physical, emotional, and financial challenges as a result of their exploitation.

While each case is unique, victims may be eligible for various forms of support and compensation, including:

  • Access to medical and mental health services.
  • Assistance in finding safe housing and reintegration into society.
  • Compensation through victim compensation programs or civil lawsuits against the perpetrators.
  • Support in navigating the legal system as witnesses.

It is crucial for survivors to connect with victim support organizations and legal professionals who specialize in assisting sex trafficking victims to understand their rights and access the services and resources available to them.

How to report sex trafficking and help the investigation?

If you suspect sex trafficking or wish to report information that may be helpful in an investigation, it is important to take the following steps:

  1. Contact local law enforcement or the appropriate authorities responsible for handling sex trafficking cases.
  2. Provide as much detailed information as possible, such as names, descriptions, locations, and any specific incidents or evidence you may have witnessed or obtained.
  3. Do not intervene directly or attempt a rescue operation, as this could jeopardize the safety of the victims and the ongoing investigation.
  4. Seek support from victim support organizations or hotlines that can provide guidance and additional resources.

By reporting suspected sex trafficking and cooperating with law enforcement agencies, you can play a crucial role in bringing down these criminal networks and helping victims find justice and support.

Karen McDonald for Oakland County Prosecuting Attorney

Karen McDonald

When it comes to the role of a prosecuting attorney, choosing the right candidate for the job is crucial. Karen McDonald is a candidate running for Oakland County Prosecuting Attorney, and her extensive experience and commitment to justice make her a strong contender for the position.

What does a prosecuting attorney do?

A prosecuting attorney, also known as a prosecutor, is a legal professional who represents the state or the government in criminal cases. Their primary responsibility is to present the case against the defendant and seek a conviction on behalf of the public.

A prosecuting attorney’s duties include:

  • Reviewing evidence and determining whether to file criminal charges.
  • Presenting the case in court, including questioning witnesses and presenting evidence.
  • Negotiating plea bargains with defense counsel.
  • Advocating for victims and their rights throughout the legal process.
  • Maintaining contact with law enforcement agencies and collaborating on investigations.
  • Seeking appropriate sentencing for convicted individuals.

What are the qualities of a good prosecuting attorney?

When evaluating candidates for the position of prosecuting attorney, certain qualities and skills are crucial:

  • Integrity: The prosecuting attorney must uphold the highest ethical standards and demonstrate honesty and fairness in their work.
  • Legal expertise: Strong knowledge of criminal law, courtroom procedures, and the rules of evidence is essential for presenting a compelling case.
  • Effective communication: The ability to articulate complex legal concepts clearly and engage with judges, jurors, witnesses, and other stakeholders is paramount.
  • Empathy: A good prosecuting attorney should have empathy and compassion for victims and their families, supporting them through the legal process.
  • Strong work ethic: Prosecuting attorneys often handle heavy caseloads and work long hours, requiring dedication and a strong commitment to justice.

Advantages and disadvantages of electing a new prosecuting attorney

When deciding whether to elect a new prosecuting attorney, it is essential to consider the potential advantages and disadvantages:


  • Fresh perspective: A new prosecuting attorney may bring fresh ideas and a different approach to tackling crime and ensuring justice.
  • Innovative strategies: A new prosecuting attorney may implement innovative approaches to address emerging challenges in the legal system.
  • Accountability: Holding elected officials accountable through the electoral process ensures that they remain responsive to the needs and concerns of the community.


  • Learning curve: A new prosecuting attorney may require time to familiarize themselves with the caseload, local laws, and the intricacies of the criminal justice system.
  • Disruption of ongoing cases: Transitioning to a new prosecuting attorney may disrupt ongoing cases and potentially delay justice for victims.
  • Uncertainty: Electing a new prosecuting attorney introduces uncertainty, as their approach and priorities may differ from their predecessor.

Where to find the best candidate for prosecuting attorney?

When seeking the best candidate for the position of prosecuting attorney, it is crucial to evaluate their qualifications, experience, and commitment to justice.

Here are some recommended approaches to find the best candidate:

  • Research the candidates’ backgrounds and legal experience, including previous roles as prosecutors or relevant legal work.
  • Attend local candidate forums or debates to hear their views on key criminal justice issues and their plans for the position.
  • Read news articles and editorials that discuss the candidates’ track records and public perception.
  • Contact local bar associations or legal organizations for their evaluations or endorsements.
  • Engage with fellow community members, attending town hall meetings or public events where candidates may be present.

Ultimately, selecting the best candidate for prosecuting attorney requires careful consideration of their qualifications, integrity, and alignment with your priorities for the justice system.

Daniel Wiliam

Hello, I am the author of the article with the title Oakland County Prosecuting Attorney which was published on September 2, 2023 on the website Invest Detroit

Artikel Terkait

Leave a Comment